1. Grace, mercy, and peace to you from God our Heavenly Father and our Lord and Savior Jesus Christ. Amen. The message from God’s Word, as we observe Reformation Day, is taken from the Epistle lesson that was read a moment ago from Romans 3:19-28. It’s entitled, “Putting the Law in Its Proper Place,” dear brothers and sisters in Christ.
2. There was once a conversation with a mother and her son. The son was about six years old, and the mother is very keen on evangelism. She asked the son, do you think that after you grow up and live your life and die that you're going to go to heaven? The boy seemed pretty confident that he would go to heaven, so the mother probed this a little bit and said, suppose you were to stand before God, and God looked you straight in the eye and said, why should I let you into heaven? What would you say? And the boy thought for a second, and then he looked up at his mom and said, if God asked me that, I would say, because I've really tried hard to be good. Then this puzzled look came over his face for a moment, and he said, well not that good. I thought that was very perceptive for a six-year-old child, because basically most of us think that all it's going to take to be acceptable to God on the day of judgment is that we have tried, that we have done our best, and that we've been basically good with our lives. But even a six-year-old child with a limited understanding of the perfection of God and his immature understanding of his own sinfulness had to think twice and realize that his goodness was not quite good enough.
3. As we observe Reformation Day, we recognize that the Reformation not only uncovered the Good News of the Gospel, but it also put the Law of God back in its proper place in the life of the Church. It is true that today we celebrate that the Reformation recovered in the Church the Good News of the sinners’ justification by grace alone, through faith alone, on account of Christ alone. But, today we not only gives thanks to God for recovering the Gospel during the Reformation, but also God’s Law.
4. Since the time of the Reformation, Lutherans have often been criticized of cheapening God’s grace. We place such an emphasis on the sinners’ justification by faith apart from the works of the Law, that we are sometimes accused of paying little or no attention to God’s Law (also known as antinomianism). But nothing could be further from the truth! The Reformation not only uncovered the Good News of the Gospel, but it also put the Law of God back in its proper place in the life of the Church.
5. The Law of God in the time of Martin Luther had been diluted. Theologians in his day were cheapening God’s Law by teaching that while a person was not able to keep the whole thing “to a t,” that at least, by trying their best, God would give them an ‘A’ for effort. The Medieval Church came up with all sorts of activities by which you could earn brownie points for things as trivial as saying a “Hail Mary” to more rigorous activities like taking a spiritual pilgrimage to Rome and visiting relics of the saints there. So, on the final day when you had to give an account, you could say, “No, I didn’t do everything You demanded of me, but look at all of the things I did do!” This is taking God’s Law, which demands perfection, and toning it down.
6. To this sort of cheapening of the Law, the Apostle Paul says in Romans 3:19: “Stop.” He writes, “Now we know that whatever the Law says it speaks to those who are under the Law, so that every mouth may be closed, and the whole world may be held accountable to God.” Did you catch that? The Law tells us to “be quiet!” The image is a sinner on trial before God, and the Law shows him how he has no case. He should not even waste his breath trying to convince God of his righteousness. By nature, every human being is in the business of convincing God of their own righteousness, like the 6 year old boy at the beginning of our sermon who trusted in his own goodness before God’s judgment. There is no desire more fundamental to the human race than the desire to be justified. We can think of the pharisee in the Temple who justifies himself by comparing himself to others, especially the tax collector (Luke 18:9-14) or the prodigal son who returns home with his story to convince his father to receive him back (Luke 15:18-20).
7. The attempt to justify oneself before God is sometimes less obvious than we realize. Things like pilgrimages or indulgences are easy to peg as man seeking his own justification. But our attempts to justify ourselves are much more subtle than that. We tend to be in the business of making sure we have all the right answers, of living a morally pure life, or by finding the right spiritual experience. But to each and every one of our attempts at self-justification before God, the Law says, “No! It is not enough! All are condemned!” Take your filthy rags you call righteousness and get them out of here. “For by the works of the Law no human being will be justified in [God’s] sight, since through the Law comes knowledge of sin” (Romans 3:20).
8. In Thesis 1 of the Heidelberg Disputation, Martin Luther writes how the “Law of God, the most salutary doctrine of life, cannot advance humans on their way to righteousness, but rather hinders them.” The Law puts us in our place: “For all have sinned and all fall short of the glory of God” (Romans 3:23). “[All] who rely on the works of the Law are under a curse” (Galatians 3:1). When we cheapen God’s Law by assuming we are capable of keeping it by our own strength, we risk losing the Gospel!
9. This is why we celebrate not only the Gospel on Reformation Sunday, but also the Law. God’s Law protects the gifts of the Gospel. It keeps us from saying to God, “I realize You want to give me the very thing You demand of me, but I do not want Your charity. That is so demeaning! I would rather take a stab at fulfilling the Law myself.” Our righteous and merciful Lord will have none of this. He loves us too much to have us keep thinking we can justify ourselves.
10. God gives us His Law in order to silence our attempts at self-justification, to knock us to our knees, so we will have no choice but to look outside of ourselves and, instead, to Jesus for our justification before God in Heaven. “But now the righteousness of God has been manifested apart from the Law, …the righteousness of God through faith in Jesus Christ for all who believe” (Romans 3:21-22). The Good News we celebrate on Reformation Sunday is that our God Himself freely gives us our righteousness as a gift (Romans 3:24-25).
11. Christ alone is righteous. He alone fulfilled God’s holy and perfect Law. He alone met its demands. He kept the Law because you could not. And He did it all FOR US! Christ, who is the only Righteous One was obedient to His Father in all things, even unto the point of death, even death on a cross, where He shed His holy blood in order to cover us with His righteousness. To what lengths will our merciful Lord not go in order to give us His righteousness? He shuts us up with His Law in order to speak to us His Gospel. He takes our unrighteousness in order to give us His as a free gift.
12. Having received such a gift, we do not have to worry about making our case before God. Instead, we can “save our breath” and use it, instead, to share the Gospel! Rather than worrying about justifying ourselves before God, we are free to love our neighbors with our words and deeds. The Law always accuses, but it does not only accuse! The Law becomes a good thing for us who have been justified by God’s grace. The Law of God is good and wise! It shows us not only our sin, but also how to love our neighbors. It guides us in our lives as freed and forgiven Christians. Praise God that He used Martin Luther and other reformers to put both the Law and the Gospel in their proper place for our lives as Christians. Amen. Now the peace of God that passes all understanding, guard your hearts and minds in Christ Jesus, until life everlasting. Amen.